Leopoldo Lopez and the injustice of Venezuela’s judicial system

Even if you don't agree with the Venezuelan opposition's call for "la salida" of President Maduro, leaders like Leopoldo Lopez, now in prison almost 15 months, still have the right to demand the resignation of a president--a right Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff rightly supported in her country. Here's his parents' story.

Author

  • Christopher Sabatini

    Dr. Christopher Sabatini, is a senior fellow for Latin America at Chatham House, and was formerly a lecturer in the School of International and Public Affairs (SIPA) at Columbia University. Chris is also on the advisory boards of Harvard University’s LASPAU, the Advisory Committee for Human Rights Watch's Americas Division, and of the Inter-American Foundation. He is also an HFX Fellow at the Halifax International Security Forum. He is a frequent contributor to policy journals and newspapers and appears in the media and on panels on issues related to Latin America and foreign policy. Chris has testified multiple times before the U.S. Senate and the U.S. House of Representatives. In 2015, Chris founded and directed a new research non-profit, Global Americas and edited its news and opinion website. From 2005 to 2014 Chris was senior director of policy at the Americas Society and Council of the Americas (AS/COA) and the founder and editor-in-chief of the hemispheric policy magazine Americas Quarterly (AQ). At the AS/COA, Dr. Sabatini chaired the organization’s rule of law and Cuba working groups. Prior to that, he was director for Latin America and the Caribbean at the National Endowment for Democracy, and a diplomacy fellow with the American Association for the Advancement of Science, working at the US Agency for International Development’s Center for Democracy and Governance. He provides regular interviews for major media outlets, and has a PhD in Government from the University of Virginia.

Former Mayor of Chacao and one of the leaders of the Venezuelan opposition, Leopoldo López, has spent almost 15 months already in the military prison, Ramo Verde, charged by the government for inciting violence.

His trial has dragged on since September, with hearings held with regularity some months and then in others—as happened in April—ending abruptly with no advance notice and no apparent plans to restart them. But not only are the hearings convened at the apparent discretion of a judicial system stacked by and acting on behalf of the government of President Nicolás Maduro, they are also closed to the media. Supposedly, if you’re in the audience you can’t even take notes in the courtroom.

Given the quality of the government’s case, though, you really can’t blame them for dragging their feet on the trial and closing it off to public scrutiny. One of the Maduro government’s major charges is that López was sending subliminal messages to his followers, subtly—but insidiously!—telling them to rebel. (Honestly, does anyone still believe in subliminal messaging? Didn’t that go out in the 1970s with ESP and the Amazing Kreskin?) And true to form, in a recent hearing, one of the government witnesses, a telecoms expert, reported as evidence of López’s nefarious activities that on one of the days of the protest his cell phone received no domestic calls but several international calls.

If there was ever a Perry Mason gotcha moment in a trial has to be it, right? International calls? I would say the guy’s definitely guilty….except that I probably receive at least six international calls a day on my cell phone, from reporters, from friends, from colleagues, I can’t keep track. I guess I shouldn’t go to Venezuela.

This would all be ridiculously laughable until you meet his parents. His mother, whom I saw only three days after Mothers’ Day, and father show the stress of having their son arbitrarily incarcerated and confined to solitary confinement. In talking to them, a parent can’t help but struggle to understand what they must be going through: fear for their son’s safety and what he must be going through. But for Leo’s mother and father, there is also pride for their son’s stubborn, unbreakable commitment to democratic principles and their country.

In fact, after meeting with them, I couldn’t help but feel inspired by their familial pride and patriotism.

Their son continues to stand up to the head of Ramo Verde, Army Colonel Homero Miranda, with little fear of the potential consequences. And let’s be honest, a government that charges a political opponent with such laughable charges, drags out the hearings and then moves him to solitary confinement in a two-meter-by-two-meter cell can pretty much do anything they want to him behind closed doors.

And they have. When he locked the door to his cell in July to prevent being attacked by masked guards (as he had been before), they took a blow torch and removed the door. When they attempted to restrict the number of books he could have in his cell, he insisted on continuing to read by just swapping the books he read with new ones provided by his family in some sort of parody of a public library. And when a group of six guards ominously told him to put on his shoes so he could be moved, he refused—and they did nothing.

Now that I think about it, maybe one of the most laughable elements of this story isn’t the charges and case that the government has mounted against a peaceful political protestor, it’s that he continues to stand up to and even taunt his tormentors. It’s enough to make a mother—and father—proud.

More Commentary

Explainer: Free Trade Agreements under Trump

With right-left polarization amongst the region’s politicians, and growing U.S.-China competition among its economies, Latin America’s most likely response to any U.S. trade actions will be further intra-regional conflict and division.

Read more >
Scroll to Top